After the demolition of a spire, a body is uncovered from the rubble. Trickster and seasonal worker Arlo Amuse-Bouche (Chris Leveille) helps to piece together the events involving a lizard man, a potential superhero, and pub trivia.
When a waiter is found dead at the Met Gala, the boys talk to celebrity Elizabethian Cowgirl (Spencer Litzinger), famous for having a good name before a particular photo removed her from the limelight.
While a foley artist by day, Cory Stanley (Brandon Hackett) 's true passion is bird watching. It was during a trip to the woods he discovered the murdered corpse of his childhood friend. They mainly talk about this; and also to a parrot.